True Horror Stories Quiz

By: Alia Hoyt
Estimated Completion Time
2 min
True Horror Stories Quiz
Image: TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP/GettyImages

About This Quiz

Who needs the movies for a good scare when you have these true tales that are 10 times worse to keep you up at night?
What was the inspiration for "A Nightmare on Elm Street"?
Wes Craven had a series of really bad dreams.
the conviction of Frederick Krueger, a serial murderer who killed people in their sleep
several reports of people who were scared to go to sleep, and then died
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Craven developed the concept after reading articles describing Asian refugees who feared the nightmares they alleged awaited them … only to die in their sleep of unknown causes.

Which notorious serial killer kept the genitals of some of his victims as souvenirs?
David Berkowitz
Jeffrey Dahmer
Ted Bundy
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

From 1978 to 1991 Jeffrey Dahmer killed 17 men, typically engaging in molestation, necrophilia and even consuming their flesh. He sometimes held onto sick "trophies," such as their heads or private parts.

Kitty Genovese was stabbed to death in 1964 over the span of a half hour. How many people allegedly saw the crime but failed to report it?
one
five
38
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Thirty-eight people were believed to have witnessed the murder, but none of them took action. The phenomenon has since been dubbed "the bystander effect." However a 2014 book stated that the figure was not correct and most of Genovese's neighbors never saw her after the first minute as she disappeared from view.

Advertisement

Which of the following was NOT an unfortunate amenity in hotelier H.H. Holmes' "Murder Castle"?
acid vat
guillotine
crematorium
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

H.H. Holmes, believed by many to be America's first serial killer, rented rooms to unsuspecting tourists during the 1893 Chicago World's Fair, many of whom were subsequently tortured, killed and disposed of. His exact number of victims is not known, but might reach as high as 200.

Which horror story legend was brought to real life at the Capri Motel in Kansas City, Missouri?
A guest was murdered in the shower.
A dead body was discovered under the bed.
Bloody Mary scared someone to death.
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

A man spent three nights in a room at the motel, all the while complaining to management about an unbearable odor. He finally checked out, and when the cleaning crew lifted up the mattress they discovered a terribly decomposed body. And you thought bed bugs were bad!

Which of the following atrocities happened to a woman named Essie Dunbar in 1915?
She was buried alive.
She was murdered with an ice pick.
She fell in a vat of boiling oil.
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Declared dead following a seizure, Dunbar's sister insisted on seeing her body after the dirt had already been piled on her casket. Workers dutifully uncovered her to appease the grieving sister, and when the lid was raised Dunbar sat up and smiled at everyone. Probably wasn't a clean pair of pants for a mile around after that sight.

Advertisement

Who killed 2-year-old James Bulger in 1992?
his mother
two 10-year-old boys
a homeless veteran
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Robert Thompson and Jon Venables, both 10 years old at the time, had been engaged in petty shoplifting all day, but at some point decided to kidnap the toddler in plain sight of security cameras at a shopping center and eventually murdered him.

Which disorder fueled Hiroshi Maeue's killer instincts?
undefined psychosis
schizophrenia
paraphilic psychosexual disorder
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

The Japanese man trolled the internet looking for people interested in engaging in suicide pacts. Upon meeting his prey, however, he killed them himself. His affliction basically meant that he could only achieve sexual gratification when he watched others suffer.

How did Macedonian journalist Vlado Taneski manage to write such in-depth features about a series of murders?
The killer tied him up and forced him to watch.
The killer sent videos of the crimes directly to him.
He was the killer.
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

A journalist for 20 years, Taneski wrote articles about the unexplained murders of three women. His major goof, however, was including too many unreleased details in his reports. Police matched his DNA to the killer's and he was arrested. He committed suicide in prison by drowning in a bucket of water.

Advertisement

What was Jesse Pomeroy's distinguishing feature?
a scar from mouth to ear
a pronounced limp
a white eye
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

Known as America's youngest serial killer, Pomeroy killed at least two children, but probably many more before being imprisoned at age 14. One of his eyes had a white film covering the pupil.

Which of these happened at the farm known as Hinterkaifeck before a family was murdered there?
A trail of footprints led from the forest to the house, but not back again.
The family received unmarked packages full of pictures of themselves.
Swarms of flies invaded the farm.
Correct Answer
Wrong Answer

A trail of footprints led from the forest to the house at Hinterkaifeck, but no footprints led away. Six residents of the farm were murdered, and the killer was never found.

You Got:
/11
TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP/GettyImages