1. Gary
   Kiki
2. Quinn

The original Midnight Society consisted of Gary, Betty Ann, Kiki, Frank, Kristen, David and Eric. Quinn joined the show later.

1. Tucker
   Frank
2. Betty Ann

Gary's younger brother Tucker -- played by Daniel DeSanto -- was the only spooky storyteller to take part in both incarnations of the series.

1. Gary
   David
2. Eric

Ross Hull played Gary, who founded the modern version of the Midnight Society and was also the grandson of the original founder.

1. Salazar
   Sardo
2. Sander

That creepy magic shop was run by Sardo -- no "mister," accent on the do. Sardo typically appeared in Gary's stories, where he sold haunted objects to unsuspecting kids.

1. Dr. Vink
   Dr. Van
2. Dr. Wolf

Dr. Vink appeared in many of Frank's stories, often in the role of a mad scientist. Like Sardo, he was constantly telling others how to pronounce his name -- Vink with a va-va-va!

1. 3
   5
2. 7

"Are You Afraid of the Dark?" spent seven seasons scaring kids. The show premiered in 1990 and ran until 1996, then came back from 1999 to 2000, for a total of 91 episodes.

1. air
   hole
2. coin

In the very first episode, Denny and Buzz must answer a riddle to escape a taxi driven by a dead man. Luckily, they are able to determine that it's a hole that has no weight, can be seen by the naked eye and makes a barrel lighter when it's added.

1. Bozo
   Zappo
2. Zeebo

When Josh steals the nose of Zeebo the clown, the terrifying clown leaves the funhouse and comes after Josh to reclaim what's rightfully his.

1. mirror
   well
2. trunk of a car

After spending much of the episode bullying her cousin Amanda, Beth becomes trapped in a mirror, leaving Amanda to save her.

1. Miss Woodley
   Miss Clove
2. Miss Tilly

Kevin and Dougie get more than they bargained for when Miss Clove gives them a twisted claw on Halloween -- a parody of the classic "Monkey's Paw" story.

1. true
2. false

It may have been a show for kids, but the characters didn't always live happily ever after. In "The Tale of the Pinball Wizard" for instance, Ross is doomed to live inside of a pinball machine forever after playing on the job.

1. "Jaws"
   "The Wolf Man"
2. "Nosferatu"

Vink hatches an evil plan that involves playing the 1922 horror classic "Nosferatu" at a local theater. When this brings real vampires into the world of the living, the theater manager tries to stop him, but Vink simply buys the theater so he can show scary movies every night of the week.

1. chemistry explosion
   car crash
2. serial killer

Back in the '60s, student Candy Warren was killed in a chemistry explosion. When new girl Julie is assigned to locker No. 22, she has the chance to go back in time and prevent the explosion to save Candy.

1. Salazar
   Shandu
2. Merlin

Shandu is a magician who casts spells using the incantation "Shandu can do!" When his assistant Todd steals Shandu's wand to help his mom, he ends up releasing an evil spirit.

1. summer camp
   cruise ship
2. boarding school

Jazz and Augie get way more than they bargained for when they are sent to boarding school and learn that the directors of the school are actually breeding an ancient race of lizard-like monsters.

1. fear
   poisoned mushrooms
2. arsenic

Dr. Vink is back. As owner of a restaurant called The Wild Mushroom, he is crafting a special soup made from the fear of his employees.

1. gold
   jewels
2. spyglass

Rush opens an old chest at Sardo's Magic Mansion and finds a spyglass inside. He takes the spyglass home only to unleash the wrath of long-dead pirate Jonas Cutter.

1. Sardo
   Dr. Vink
2. Shandu

Even a villain can do a good deed once in a while. It's mad scientist Dr. Vink -- who's now running a barbershop -- who saves the day when a pirate ghost kidnaps Max.

1. scarecrow
   vampire
2. wolf

Anne and Jared find a scarecrow in the wall of an old barn. The scarecrow is handy at first, helping the kids with chores, but soon starts to resent his role as a servant.

1. ghost
   comic book character
2. singer

In "The Tale of the Ghastly Grinner," Ethan brings an evil comic book character to life and must help his friend complete another comic to create a hero to defeat the Grinner.

1. a pirate
   a dog
2. a prisoner

On a visit to an old prison, Scott and Jason release the spirit of escaped prisoner One-Eyed Jack. With the help of the ghost, they learn that Jack never actually escaped the prison and has been stuck in a ventilation shaft for 50 years.

1. a hotel key
   a jukebox
2. a board game

When their family moves into an old inn with the intention of fixing the place up, Lisa and Jason discover that the old jukebox at the inn is the secret to reuniting a pair of long-dead lovers.

1. prison
   a cave
2. a shipwreck

When a group of boys go camping in the woods, they are pursued by spooky creatures known as Manaha. After freeing the spirit of a Shaman from a cave, the Shaman tries to sacrifice the boys to the creatures.

1. Gary
   Quinn
2. Kiki

Gary moves from storyteller to main character in "The Tale of the Silver Sight," when he must reunite the original 1937 members of the Midnight Society in order to defeat powerful black magic.

1. Ryan Reynolds
   Justin Timberlake
2. Ryan Gosling

Ryan Gosling was almost a permanent cast member on the show, but turned down the role so he could join the Mickey Mouse Club. Later, he appeared on one episode, "The Tale of Station 109.1."

1. 13
   21
2. 65

"The Tale of the Nightshift" was the 65th episode of the show and was supposed to be the series finale. The number 65 appeared on the hospital door at the end, and the campfire was left burning to signify the end of the series.

1. Murder
   Help Me
2. It was Jack

The young ghost in "The Tale of the Lonely Ghost" writes "Help Me" all over the walls -- but backwards, so it can be read through a mirror. At the end of the story, Amanda helps reunite the ghost with her mother, Nanny.

1. 2 weeks
   3 months
2. 6 months

The scary story fans in the Midnight Society needed only 2 to 3 weeks to film all of their scenes each year.

1. ashes
   dust
2. creamer

Production chose non-dairy creamer to serve as the midnight dust on the show. As the cast tossed a handful of creamer on the fire, the flames would ignite and produce a spooky flume of white smoke.

1. true
2. false

Believe it or not, it was Dr. Seuss who inspired the title of the show. Creator D.J. McHale chose the title based on a Seuss story called "What Was I Scared Of?" that he enjoyed as a child.