Was It Gunsmoke or Bonanza?

By: Gavin Thagard
Estimated Completion Time
2 min
Hop Sing, a Chinese immigrant, was a family cook in this show.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
Hop Sing was a welcomed member of the Cartwright household, usually very considerate of others. However, he would get angry when the family showed up to dinner late.

Advertisement

This show is famous for the line "Get the hell out of Dodge."
Gunsmoke
This line became an idiom in popular culture after it was heard on the show. Occasionally, it still comes up today.
Bonanza

Advertisement

This show was set in Dodge City, Kansas.
Gunsmoke
Dodge City is an actual city in Kansas. It was founded in 1872 and incorporated in 1875.
Bonanza

Advertisement

Kitty Russell owned the Long Branch Saloon.
Gunsmoke
When the show originally ran, many fans wondered if Matt Dillon and Kitty Russell were ever in an actual relationship on the show. Over 40 years later, those fans are still asking the same question.
Bonanza

Advertisement

This show featured the Ponderosa Ranch.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
The Ponderosa Ranch was located near Lake Tahoe in Nevada. A real ranch named after the one in the show was used as an amusement park from 1967 until 2004.

Advertisement

This show follows Marshall Matt Dillon.
Gunsmoke
Gunsmoke started off as a radio series. Matt Dillon was voiced by William Conrad on the radio and played by James Arness on the show.
Bonanza

Advertisement

The main character was widowed three times.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
Cowboys aren't meant to settle down. That was certainly the case for Ben Cartwright, though not by choice.

Advertisement

Dr. Galen Adams is the town physician.
Gunsmoke
Dr. Galen Adams was played by Milburn Stone. Stone was awarded an Emmy in 1968 for his portrayal of the character on Gunsmoke.
Bonanza

Advertisement

There's a bartender named Sam Noonan.
Gunsmoke
Sam Noonan was played by Glenn Strange. Strange died in 1973 of lung cancer while still a character on the show.
Bonanza

Advertisement

Sheriff Roy Coffee ran the town.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza​
Sheriff Coffee was up in age and many people considered him unfit to run the town. In the episode "No Less a Man," he proves them wrong by running off a gang of thieves.

Advertisement

The Cartwright family is a big part of this show.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
Originally, the Cartwright family is made up of Ben Cartwright and his three sons. For most of the series, none of them are married. This was more of a studio decision than a story decision, as married men were unpopular on television at the time.

Advertisement

Dusty Rhoades becomes a foreman.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
Dusty Rhoades is an old friend of Ben Cartwright. He brings Jamie Hunter to the Cartwright's ranch.

Advertisement

In this show, "Candy" Canaday is a former Army brat.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
"Candy" Canaday left the Army and became a cowboy on the Cartwright's ranch. Eventually, he climbed the ranks and became the ranch foreman.

Advertisement

Quint Asper is a blacksmith in this show.
Gunsmoke
Quint Asper was half-Comanche, often referred to as a "halfbreed." He struggles with his commitment to the tribe and to justice.
Bonanza

Advertisement

Will Mannon argues that he's the fastest gun in the West.
Gunsmoke
Will Mannon uses brutality to draw out Matt Dillon and get the duel of a lifetime. However, he should be careful what he wishes for.
Bonanza

Advertisement

In a two-episode plot, killer Charlie Hacker is chased to Mexico.
Gunsmoke
In the late 19th century, Mexico is full of corrupt officials and bandits. That won't stop Marshall Matt Dillon from catching the bad guy.
Bonanza

Advertisement

This show had an episode called "The Hidden Enemy" about substance abuse.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
Substance abuse was only one issue the show dealt with. It also discussed domestic violence and environmental issues, among many others.

Advertisement

In the series premiere, an actress is used to gain a hostage in exchange for timber wood.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
It all started with a mining tycoon and an actress. With the Cartwright family solving this dilemma, the show was off and running.

Advertisement

Festus Haggen was a deputy on the show.
Gunsmoke
Festus Haggen arrives in Dodge City after the death of his twin brother. After his first appearance, his twin brother is never brought back up. Some things are better left forgotten.
Bonanza

Advertisement

In this show, Mr. Norton expels a Jewish student.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
Bonanza wasn't afraid to dive into issues like anti-semitism. Luckily, the morally guided Ben Cartwright is always willing to step in and have his view heard.

Advertisement

In "The Lonely Man," a Chinese man can't marry a white woman because of territorial laws.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
The Cartwright's cook, Hop Sing, falls in love with a white woman and asks her to marry him. Sadly, the marriage never occurs because of race laws governing the region.

Advertisement

This show had an episode about Mormons called "The Pursued."
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
"The Pursued" is a two-part episode in season 8. In the two episodes, the Cartwright family must stand between the town and a family of Mormons who owns a ranch. This is another storyline showing the boundaries​ this show was willing to push.

Advertisement

Jamie Hunter is a red-headed orphan.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
Jaime is eventually adopted by Ben Cartwright. This gives the father of the Cartwright's another ear to teach lessons to.

Advertisement

Clayton Thaddeus Greenwood was a deputy on the show.
Gunsmoke
Clayton "Thad" Greenwood has an episode titled after him. In the episode, Thad comes to Dodge City to arrest criminals with a warrant that's no good outside Oklahoma​.
Bonanza

Advertisement

In "Zavala," a gang of outlaws terrorizes the village of Zavala.
Gunsmoke
In the episode, Matt Dillon forms a friendship with Paco, a boy from the village. Paco respects Dillon's desire to arrest the outlaws instead of killing them.
Bonanza

Advertisement

An African-American opera singer named Thomas Bowers comes to town.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
This was a controversial episode, especially in the 1960s. Two television stations in the South wouldn't air it.

Advertisement

Clem Foster was a deputy on the show.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
Clem Foster first appears in the episode "Half a Rogue." In the episode, "Hoss" Cartwright is wrongfully accused of a murder and has to prove his innocence.

Advertisement

In the episode "Ex-Con," the main character is framed for murder.
Gunsmoke
Marshall Matt Dillon goes to sleep sick in an abandoned shack. When he wakes up, he's been framed for murder. Next time, he'll be careful before he falls asleep.
Bonanza

Advertisement

This show featured a parolee named Griff King who was trying to reform his life.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
Griff King didn't make his first appearance on the show until the final season. Seeking redemption, he was quickly put under the guidance of Ben Cartwright, working on the Cartwright ranch.

Advertisement

In the episode "Lover Boy," Kyle Kelly is a charming cowboy who breaks hearts.
Gunsmoke
Kyle Kelly was played by Ken Curtis. Curtis was also a guest star in four other episodes, though as different characters.
Bonanza

Advertisement

In "The Sharecropper," the town deputy shoots a man in the leg by accident, so he brings the man back to his house.
Gunsmoke
This was the final episode of the popular show Gunsmoke. It wasn't written as a series finale, as both cast and crew expected to have a 21st season.
Bonanza

Advertisement

In the episode "Robin Hood," witnesses refuse to turn in a man who robs rich people.
Gunsmoke
"Robin Hood" follows the criminal John Henry Jordan who saves his crimes for the wealthy. He's eventually stopped after being forced to go after the poor as well.
Bonanza

Advertisement

A former soldier, Bill Tanner, goes on a killing spree.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
Bill Tanner sets his eyes on "Little Joe" Cartwright. Joe survives the encounter, but in future years, he dies in the Spanish-American War.

Advertisement

Alice Harper is murdered with her brother John over a gambling debt.
Gunsmoke
Bonanza
In this two-part episode, "Little Joe" Cartwright falls in love and marries Alice Harper. However, their marriage ends with Alice's murder, and "Little Joe" seeks revenge.

Advertisement

In the episode "The Queue," a Chinese man has his pigtail cut off and must seek retribution.
Gunsmoke
Chen, a Chinese immigrant, has his pigtail cut off by two men. He claims that he can't return to China without killing the men, which is a lot to go through for hair.
Bonanza

Advertisement

You Got:
/35
Featured